Now, every summer will be different, and last year, we probably needed to shoot for 88-90 because of the likely multitude of defections. Next summer will hopefully be better, although if there is a coaching change expect a similar half dozen or more departures in the next two years. But even if Richt stays, signing for 85 is a problem. Kids do things, and there's a million reasons one might leave early, from the NFL to academics to homesickness and on and on. Targeting 86-88 is just good business knowing that at least 1-3 kids you expect to be there in the spring won't be come fall. You live, you learn, we just wish Richt had learned quicker on issues like this. If he hadn't held to his upstanding morals, which were self-damaging morals, we wouldn't be in this situation. Hopefully the cold-blooded sausage making of SEC football means we'll be delving into the gray a little more going forward on this black and white ethical issue.
SPORTS AND GRITS-- Expert Bloggery on all things SEC, Southern,and Georgia. Georgia's Number One Outlaw Site. Banned by a Few for Content, Hated by Many for its Realness, Feared by More for its Truth, Respected by All for its Balls. Hardcore Legends of Georgia/Southern Football Bloggery, and Cold-blooded Sausage Makers.
Tuesday, September 13, 2011
Oversigning is a good idea
ECDawg has something on it over at leatherhelmet. And while every year will be different, we hope this current season has shown Richt the light (if he's still around) on the benefits of targetting just over 85 on that first Wednesday in February. We have severe depth issues at LB and RB, as well as OL. Issues that might not be here if we had signed like we were about to have a summer full of defections that we all knew were coming in the housecleaning. Or if we had signed another couple players the last few years instead of leaving 3-5 ships to reward walk-ons. But that's in the past, and all we ca do is address the future.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
saban uses the carrot and stick approach with the stick being over signing and getting rid of the ones that don't want to work hard.
ReplyDeleteSaban isn't as bad as Nutt or Petrino with it either. But imo, there is a difference between what Saban does (signing to excess and cutting any kid who falls below a certain level), what Petrino does (Saban, but on a larger scale it seems), what Nutt does (hedging his bets with numerous potential academic nonqualifiers to place them or get in good with certain coaches/schools), and what we're proposing, which is oversigning above 85, but within reason for expected departures and natural factors removing kids. Basically, I don't want to get back in the 70s in total #s again. If some kids leave unexpectedly, and you end up around 82 or 83, that's workable. But you should shoot for having 84 or 85 scholarshipped athletes every season. And if one or two kids in a five year span who are otherwise good kids but aren't pulling their weight end up "graduating early", taking a "medical hardship" or just transfer to Ga Southern, Ga St, or Valdosta St for "more playing time", so be it.
ReplyDelete