In spite of all the negativity in the blogosphere, and three guys in Augusta doing their damnedest to sabotage all the coaches' hard work in Athens, Georgia brought in a stellar signing day class. With a little time to assess these things, we offer our review of the signees below. But before we start, we'd like to point out how 2012 looks as good, if not better, than the 2011 crop. Already in tow are WRs CJ Curry and Lonnie Outlaw, DL Jalen Fields, and K Marshall Morgan, as well as probable out of state 5 stars Keith Marshall (RB, NC) and John Theus (OL, FL), among other elite out of state targets (as Richt has said, with the plethora of talent in GA, you better be good if we're crossing the state line to come after ya) and what's said to be even better in state talent to pick from the Empire State of the South in 2012. So the future looks bright here, while the $2,800,000 question is can Richt get enough out of it to bring back 2002-2007 glory instead of 2009/2010 disappointments. But here's the official Sports and Grits review of Georgia's 2011 signees.
QB Christian Lemay-Great pickup. One of the top QBs in this class, plus he enrolls early (which in our opinion, a spring in Athens is more beneficial than his senior season would have been). Provides quality depth behind Murray and Mason, and probably surpasses Mason to replace Murray as a redshirt junior in 2014. Grade, A-.
RB Isaiah Crowell-Like the QB spot, it's small, but ideal. As reports of Washaun Ealey and Caleb King possibly departing, it'd have been nice if there was one more name here for depth (Josh Clemons?), but if at least one of the 2 older players can get back in Richt's good graces, we should be fine. Plus, there is a clear need for the aforementioned Marshall in the 2012 class, and even better from our eyes, no fullbacks! We lost Chapas and Munzanmeier, but have Xander Ogletree and probably a walk-0n or 3 that could be a backfield pulling G. Not signing a FB is great to us, if it means we start to putting more threats on the field making our "pro-style" offense look more like the pros current "style". Grade, A-.
WR Malcolm Mitchell, Sanford Seay, Justin Scott-Wesley, Chris Conley A good 4 man set at a position of need. Good size, as all but Scott-Wesley are listed over 6', all have good speed with Scott-Wesley in particular having great track times. Conley is reported the most polished as a WR, Seay may have the most in terms of physical tools, Scott-Wesley the fastest, and Mitchell the most explosive play-maker. It's a bit disheartening that in spite of a top 5 pick in Green, a talented young QB in Murray, and an offense in need of an impact player there, we couldn't hit a top 10 guy, but this is still a solid group that should produce plenty of big plays. Grade, B+.
TE Jay Rome A big time player, and arguably the top TE in the country. Size, strength, route running, play making, pedigree, Rome has it all. Ideally, we'd have loved to haul in Nick O'Leary as well as Rome, to continue the Georgia tradition of multiple match up problems at TE (Watson and McMichael, McMichael and Johnson, Brown and Wiggins, Pope and Milner, White and Charles) but that'd just be greedy and personal as we like two TE offenses. But Rome was a big time player, and although the depth chart might delay his impact (Figgins, White, Charles, and Lynch leave little open playing time), he should make a significant contribution in the next 4-5 years. Grade, A.
OL Watts Dantzler, Zach Debell, Xzavier Ward, David Andrews, Hunter Long, Nathan Theus 6 names, and while there isn't a lot of star power there, it's a great class. Andrews seems like an ideal heir apparent to Ben Jones, and Hunter Long provides another potential quality interior OL. Ward and Debell provide a pair of long athletes with ideal feet and athleticism for OT. They need to add weight, but it's a lot easier to add weight on to a wide framed 250-260 pound 18yr old than it is to take it off as they mature. Dantzler has that size listed 300+, and is said to be an ideal RT prospect. Theus is more a long snapper than OL, but seems to have the size to possible add depth inside and said to be an NFL caliber snapper (which no one notices unless they mess up). OL recruiting is always hit or miss, as it's hard to project how guys this big will do in HS when they are so much bigger and stronger than their competition. But you can make up for quality in quantity, while the quality is still pretty good, and an improved S&C program should go a long way into making an improved OL going forward. Grade, B+.
DL John Jenkins, Chris Mayes, Sterling Bailey, Ray Drew They say Drew starts at OLB, but at 6'5, 250 or so, we see him getting bigger and ultimately putting his hand on the ground. Bailey is similar to Drew, with the size and athleticism to develop into a great 3-4 DT/DE (depending on what you term them). Mayes is also a great big athlete for the 3-4 DL, but is said to be questionable academically. But Drew and Jenkins are the headliners here. Drew is an all-world talent, and one of the Dream Team leaders. He has the tools to be an impact this year, a first round pick in 3 years, and his attitude sounds ideal. Jenkins is supposedly the missing piece as a 3-4 NG. 350 or so, and can move are rare, and he is said to be just that. We here at S&G think the Mt. Cody comparisons are a bit much, and would be satisfied if he's another Gerald Anderson or Donnan JUCO type contributor (Emarlos Leroy, Jermaine Smith, Jason Ferguson). We've had good, albeit varied, success with JUCO DL, from Donnan's trio to more recently Jarius Wynn and Corvey Irvin. We'd have liked a few more though, as the DL was the weakest link last year defensively, and even if Jenkins is all he's been hyped to be, he can't play every snap and we could use some help behind him, Deangelo Tyson, and probably Abry Jones as the starting DL. Grade, B+ with Drew, B- without him.
LB Kent Turene, Ramik Wilson, Amarlo Herrera, Quintavious Harrow We missed Dickson from Griffin, and the main 3 all project to ILB not OLB. The team has several physical talents already, and Wilson, Turene, and Herrera all sound like great additions to the ILB core. Thick, powerful, smart, between the 3 there should be at least one stud produced (which is good if you go by historical averages). We put Harrow here because he's a HS LB and players don't generally go farther from the line of scrimmage as they step up. With his elite speed, we think Harrow puts on some pounds, and ideally follows the career arc of Marcus Howard. All in all, it's a decent group, with a great ILB group but a lot to be desired in terms of OLB potential. Bailey or Drew may end up at OLB, but with their current sizes, it's easier for those guys to add size as they mature instead of stay the same weight. Not included here is sign and place Dexter Staley, who would be on the list if not for academics forcing him to take a detour at GMC. He should be a big time addition to the 2013 class. Grade, B-.
DB Damien Swann, Nick Marshall, Devin Bowman, Chris Sanders, Corey Moore Moore and Sanders were extremely early commits, and are described as a solid pair of safeties. There were a ton of players at that spot in state, including Brian Randolph, Avery Walls, and several other BCS signees, but we took Moore and Sanders early. That speaks highly of them, and the coaching staffs opinion of them. We'll see how they turn out, as several elite S prospects have disappointed (CJ Byrd, Jakar Hamilton, even Reshad Jones to an extent, among others), but both sound like excellent pick ups. Marshall is said to start at CB, and while he has elite QB tools, the demands of basketball (he's among the best Gs and will play for Mark Fox in the offseason) put him in the defensive backfield, not the offensive backfield, but his physical tools seem to lend him towards another former QB turned DB, Sean Jones. Devin Bowman has the pedigree to be a top player, and Damien Swann was the best CB from Atlanta. Both should add depth behind the two Brandon's (Smith and Boykin) next year. Swann is said to be a possible Smith with his speed and offensive potential. It's got plenty of talent, strength in numbers, and as
Doug Gillett said bring an emphatic end to Willie Martinez's past "Lollipop Guild" recruiting strategy for the position.
Grade, B+. Specialists -Theus could have gone here, but at his size, we think he gets some snaps on the OL before all is said and done. But with a trio of senior kickers, Richt resisted the urge to add one in this class to redshirt and take over later, allowing Morgan to replace Walsh next year, and perhaps a walk-on to take P after Drew Butler as Brian Mimbs and Gordon Ely-Kelso did before Butler. Grade, A.
Overall grade, B+. Yeah, we're probably being picky, but while it is a top 5 class, looking at it on the whole is still just a B+ to us. We love the marquee names, Crowell, Drew, Lemay, Marshall, Swann, Jenkins, Rome, but still see a bit to be desired. We lack a replacement for Justin Houston at OLB, could have used more DL, and lack an elite WR prospect to replace AJ Green. And while they did a great job closing, there were still a handful of misses that would have addressed those 3 lacking areas (Xzavier Dickson, Jeoffrey Pagan, Charone Peake, Terrance Smith, Corey Crawford, Deion Barnes, Toby Jackson, Ashley Lowery, Dink Fanning, Gabe Wright, and Rashad Greene, among others)